Statement from the Coalition of Mother and Baby Homes Survivors
Well known campaigner and author Paul Jude Redmond has resigned from Minister Zappone’s Survivors Forum claiming it is a ‘cynical, time wasting farce of no benefit to living survivors’. The full text of his letter of resignation is below.
Redmond is best known as the Chairperson of the ‘Coalition of Mother And Baby home Survivors (CMABS) and author of The Adoption Machine. He was born in Castlepollard Mother and Baby home in 1964 and recently met with Pope Francis during his visit. The Pope spoke about adoption and reunion during the Papal mass in the Phoenix Park after hearing from Redmond and Clodagh Malone.
Since Minister Zappone came to office in March 2016, there has no progress whatsoever on the primary demands of the adoption and survivor communities such as the Full Inclusion of all survivors of Forced Adoption and Illegal Adoption into the current ‘Inquiry into Mother and Baby homes’ due to report in February 2019 and, an immediate acknowledgement, apology and redress for an aging survivor community who are dying by the thousands as Zappone endlessly stalls.
Even the most basic supports for an elderly and dying community have been refused such as a 24 hour helpline, free counselling, and enhanced medical cards for elderly survivors. The Adoption Bill brought forward by former Minister James Reilly in 2015 and scheduled to pass in 2016 has languished on Zappone’s desk for two and a half years with zero progress.
Instead of action, Minister Zappone has stalled, broken promises, refused to meet survivors, held two ‘facilitated meetings’, set up a ‘selection panel’ and now finally a ‘Forum’ due to be reviewed after one year in August 2019.
Because of Zappone’s refusal to support or meet with survivors, Redmond said that CMABS has ‘engaged an eminent lawyer to bring a formal complaint to the united Nations Committee Against Torture about the complete lack of action on survivor issues as well as this disgusting Forum designed to side track and divide the survivor community.’
‘I am absolutely heart sick at Zappone’s latest, cynical, time wasting farce which is of no benefit to living survivors. CMABS biggest demand since 2014 has been the Full Inclusion of ALL survivors in the current Inquiry into Mother and Baby homes. However, Zappone has fought this at every opportunity and has now excluded them from the remit of the so called Survivors Forum as well as excluding any discussion of the long delayed Adoption Bill to open the adoption records. Attempts to have these issues included in the agenda of the Forum have failed and it is clear the civil servants running the Forum have their own agenda to limit and frustrate the survivor and adoption communities at every turn.
Zappone has cold heartedly refused to release the funding for Memorials promised to the community in January 2015 and has instead frivolously spent our Memorial funding on advertising a Forum to discuss the Memorials over the course of at least a year! It’s simply unbelievable. This is beyond hypocrisy and a complete waste of hundreds of thousands of Euros of taxpayers money to stall instead of taking action.
Minister Zappone’s two and half years in office has seen progress for the living survivor community stop dead and it is clear she needs to resign immediately and allow a decent and compassionate person do the job she point blank refuses to do.
My biggest regret is not listening to Derek Leinster of the Bethany Home Survivor’s Group ’98 who boycotted this Forum from the beginning declaring it would of no benefit to our community. He was correct. I decided to participate and try and turn it around and transform the Forum into a fast tracked series of recommendations to the Minister for the urgent issues our community needs addressed but, the Forum was perverted and warped from the start by Minister Zappone and her civil servants to ensure the survivor community could make no progress on the substantive issues. Zappone is guilty of one of the lowest, dirtiest, most mean spirited political tricks seen in recent years.
CMABS has engaged an eminent lawyer to bring a formal complaint to the United Nations Committee Against Torture about Zappone’s complete lack of action on survivor issues as well as this disgusting Forum designed to side track and divide the survivor community and subvert progress.’
FULL TEXT OF REDMOND’S RESIGNATION LETTER
Dear Minister Zappone, Jerry Carney and Jim Halley.
I am hereby tendering my immediate resignation from the Consultative Forum on the Mother and Baby homes.
I believed at the outset – and stated it publicly – that I believed the Forum would be a a talking shop and achieve nothing. Sadly this is the way it has turned out.
In accepting the invitation to the join the Forum I believed that I would be able to achieve something for the survivor community who were treated horrifically in the Mother and Baby homes in what was a form of ‘internment without trial’. However, I did have very serious misgivings about the way the Forum was set up and constituted. Nevertheless, I did go ahead and accept the invitation to join the Forum, in the hope as I said above, of achieving something for the living survivors of the homes as well as our fallen crib mates who were effectively neglected to death by uncaring nuns while the State turned a blind eye and handed over the cheques.
Sadly for the survivors I represent, my concerns have been borne out as regards how the Forum is being conducted. In particular, the manner in which the Forum is chaired by an ex-Secretary General of a government department was a source of great concern to me. Regardless of the calibre of the individual involved (and I accept Gerry Carney is a very decent and capable person), the Chair should have been a genuinely neutral outsider. In addition I do not think that the Chairman, a former senior Civil Servant, could be independent in a situation where the State is culpable for what happened in the Mother and Baby homes regardless of his personal integrity.
I also note for the record, that you Minister Zappone, have also politically limited the Agenda of the Forum from the start and have excluded the three most important issues on which many survivors, as represented by the Coalition of Mother And Baby home Survivors (CMABS), have campaigned; namely the Full Inclusion of ALL survivors in the current Inquiry into Mother and Baby homes and, an immediate acknowledgement, apology and redress for an aging survivors community as recommended by the Inquiry itself in its Interim report in 2017. CMABS also notes that the urgent issue of illegal adoptees has also been excluded from both the Inquiry and, now from the Forum. This is disgraceful behaviour by a Minister supposed to represent survivors and adoptees in these difficult times.
Furthermore, the way certain aspects of the Forum have transpired is a cause for further concern. For example, Chairpersons of sub committees were not appointed by objective criteria and, my efforts to have certain matters of the utmost importance moved onto the agenda, were dismissed without cause. There are several other flaws in the fundamental operation of the Forum.
CMABS are aware that a formal complaint has already been submitted to the United Nations about this Forum and, we have retained the expertise of an eminent lawyer to take our further complaints directly to the United Nations Committee Against Torture. This current political stalling and disingenuous delaying tactics cannot be allowed to continue.
I sincerely hope, as a survivor of a Mother and Baby home, that all survivors will get justice at the end of the day. However, this Forum is certainly a hindrance to that aspiration and of no practical help to the living survivor community. Meanwhile Minister Zappone, as the Forum fiddles, survivors continue dying.